In another one of my posts that will interest exactly nine other people, I plan to look at the recent 10-team fantasy baseball draft in which I participated on Monday, March 24 and make my predictions as to who will be the picks that give each team the most value over the 2008 season as well as the picks that will have the worst value relative to where they were drafted.
First of all, the league format: We play in a 10-team Yahoo! custom points league. Categories for offense are HR, RBI, SB, R, BB, 1B, 2B, and 3B. For pitchers, the categories are W, L, ER, IP, K, Hld, and SV. We have a MLB universe roster of 20 players (5 of which are bench) plus two DL spots per team. There are unlimited trades (with an August deadline) and unlimited other moves as well. The league is a daily league that has been running for five years (with a bit of turnover), but it is not a keeper league.
And by value I am, again, talking about relative to the spot where they were picked. A-Rod will have tremendous value going with the first pick, but that is expected value – what we are looking for is unexpected value or expected value not achieved.
So without any more rambling, here are (in my opinion) the best and worst value draft picks by team, in order of how we drafted.
1. Eric Ramirez
Best pick – Josh Hamilton – 13th round
In half a season last year, the rookie with the troubled past totaled 19 HR and 47 RBI in only 337 plate appearances. This year, he has a guaranteed starting spot on the Rangers and is going to a park that might be the best in the majors for left handed power hitters. Some of the OF taken in the two rounds before Hamilton include Jermaine Dye, Matt Kemp, Jose Guillen and Delmon Young. My guess is that Hamilton out-homers all those guys. In a quick glance at eight popular projection systems, his average home run prediction from all of those is 21. If he stays healthy, he will fly past that number in Arlington
Worst pick – Derrek Lee – 6th round
Not so much that it was a bad pick in the 6th round, but because power is the most sought-after commodity in our league, it was a questionable strategy to wait until the 6th for a 1B – the premium power position. At that point, it may have been wise to wait and grab Carlos Pena, Paul Konerko or Ryan Garko – all of whom went in much later rounds. At age 32, Lee is not the 46/107 guy from three years ago, but he is also not the 22/82 guy from last year. His mean lies somewhere in the middle – but he is just too inconsistent for me as a sixth pick.
2. Kirk Kornegay
Best pick – Joakim Soria – 20th round
I almost had this pegged as Scott Kazmir in the 9th round, but his current injury gives me just a little bit of concern, so Soria is the choice. The Royals play a lot of close games due to an offense that is in the bottom half of the AL. And that is good for a closer, especially one with Soria’s numbers. Soria posted a VORP of 26.4 in 2007 – higher than any of his other Royal teammates. His ERA, WHIP, K/9, K/BB, and BAA were all outstanding in 2007. His BABIP was .264, showing he was a bit lucky, and therefore likely causing a slight bump up in his other peripherals in 2008. However, a closer with 25+ save potential in the last round is a steal.
Worst pick – John Lackey – 7th round
We all know how incredible Lackey has been as a pitcher recently. He was the third best pitcher in the AL last season, and thanks to a significant decrease in his BB/9 and a sharp increase in his LOB%, Lackey made the jump from 13-14 wins per season to 19, and an ERA in the mid-3’s to exactly 3.01. But a strained triceps injury on his throwing arm currently leaves Lackey on the shelf for all of April. Five months from Lackey could still make up for the lost time, especially with an improved offense, but pitchers such as Harang, Oswalt, Beckett and Matsuzaka were still on the board for this pick.
3. Jeremy Gibson
Best pick – H. Bell and R. Betancourt – Rounds 16 and 17
The combined numbers for these two pitchers in 2007 looks like this:
11 wins, 172 IP, 34 ER, 182 Ks, 65 holds, and an ERA around 1.80
Those are fabulous numbers for the amount of innings they account for (out of our 1200 total). Betancourt has some numbers from 2007 that make you feel like the numbers will dip a little, such as an astonishingly low BABIP of .246 and astonishingly high LOB% of 86.4%. Bell also makes you think a little bit because his ERAs in 2005 and 2006 were in the 5’s and his 102 Ks more than doubles anything he has ever done, but even if these pitchers see their numbers decrease by 20% across the board, the 16th and 17th rounds are great for their stats.
Worst pick – Chipper Jones – 6th round
Jones is a great player, and after last year, he clearly has plenty of offense left in that bat. Despite missing almost 30 games, Jones was 6th in the Majors in batting average and VORP and also top 12 in Runs Created (keep in mind, a cumulative stat). So while normally this would be a great pick, there is just too much injury concern for me. Jones has not played in more than 137 games since 2003 and in 2005-2006 he missed at least 50 games each season. Jeremy has an admirable back-up plan with Mike Lowell also on the roster, and I just have this feeling that he will definitely be forced into active duty on Jeremy’s team before too long. But of course this could easily end up being his best pick if it pans out and Jones stays healthy.
4. Ryan Kirksey
Best pick – Dustin McGowan – 19th round
The one pitcher I was targeting most in the late rounds this year, and I kept waiting and waiting, forcing myself to be patient in hopes on one else would take him. McGowan, now 26, saw so many things trend upward from 2006 to 2007: namely his K/9, BB/9, ERA, and WHIP. Plus, he is an extreme groundball pitcher (a great thing seeing as he will be facing some of the toughest lineups in the league on a regular basis) to the tune of 53% in 2007. An improved Blue Jays lineup certainly won’t hurt his case for wins, but a questionable bullpen might. Still, if his Ks and IP continue to go up and his BB and earned runs continue to go down, I should be happy.
Worst pick – Francisco Liriano – 12th round
I will be the hardest on myself. This was a stupid pick here. I thought a lot of people were looking for him about this time, but it turns out most people were going to wait a couple more rounds. They had probably all seen the note that came out Monday that I missed: Liriano will likely open the season with some starts in Triple-A before moving up. Guys like Carmona, Wang and Bonderman went around at that time, and I probably would have been better off with one of those. Even for a talent like Liriano, there are too many questions surrounding a return from Tommy John that I should have waited a few more picks or waited to see how he responds in real game action.
5. Regan Boudra
Best pick – Chien Ming Wang – 12th round
Probably the hardest draft to pick a best/worst value. Every pick seemed to be pretty much in line with the perceived value of the player, so these may be a stretch in a couple of areas. Regan’s quote during the draft of “I’ll take 17 wins even if he only gets 17 strikeouts” was one of the highlights, but it also rings somewhat true. Actually, Wang’s K rate improved to 4.70 per nine last year, up from 3.14 in 2006. Your standard for acceptable K/9 rates for a starter really should be around 5.6 or so, but when 59% of your balls in play are grounders, you are getting plenty of people out that way (even with Jeter and whatever lead glove they will play at first). So 17 wins is certainly achievable, I might even go one or two more for him.
Worst pick – Carlos Guillen – 6th round
I am lukewarm on Carlos Guillen as I had him in the second half of last year (the half he was just good, and not incredible), but he is just a bit too streaky in my opinion. His HR the past 5 years have been 21, 19, 5, 20, 7. His OPS: 859, 920, 803, 921, 753. RC: 99, 112, 51, 107, 55. Still, playing first should keep him on the field more and cut down on his pesky injuries. Guillen is not a bad pick here by any means, but he was the fifth SS taken after Rollins, Ramirez, Reyes and Tulo – so there were options available.
6. Tim Miller
Best pick – Kerry Wood – 20th round
Wood was officially named the Cubs’ closer earlier that day, and the Cubs look to compete in the division, so Wood should factor in many of those decisions albeit if he remains healthy. A K/9 rate of 8.9 last year in limited work is very promising (especially since it was 5.95 in 2006), but a BB/9 rate of 4.81 is decidedly not promising. He has not had a number that high since 2000, so he can certainly get it under control, but with Marmol and Howry breathing down his neck, Pinella does have options if this arm-saving move of having Wood close does not pan out.
Worst Pick – Justin Verlander – 5th round
This may be a bit of a reach on my part, because Verlander is going to be great, but he was the fifth pitcher taken overall in our draft. Only one fantasy preview source that I found (out of about 15) had Verlander ranked fifth. The average of all of those pegged Verlander at 9.4. Still on the board when Verlander went were Beckett, Sabathia, Harang, and Haren – all of whom could make a case to go ahead of Verlander. A couple of things to watch would be the interesting fact that despite the velocity of Verlander’s fastball decreasing the past three years, his K rate has increased. Watch that and his innings count (high for a young pitcher), but the offense behind him should support plenty of wins. Still, JV is Tim’s ace, and should serve him well
7. Joel Ramirez
Best pick – Edgar Renteria – 15th round
While nothing with the glove, Renteria has again turned into a force with the bat. Hitting in that stacked Detroit lineup won’t hurt anything, either. Since our league does not have a middle infielder spot, once the top ten SS went, it was a while until number 11 (Renteria) went off the board. While Joel also drafted Hanley Ramirez, a quick check of his roster shows that Renteria would be a better fit at the Util spot that anyone else in his lineup (Giambi, Rolen, etc.). Renteria has always been a great source for hits and average (although last year he was off the charts and won’t repeat that), but his OBP has also improved four straight years, something that is vital to the Tigers and to fantasy points leagues.
Worst pick – Jacque Jones and Derrick Turnbow – 17th and 18th rounds
Jones also has the benefit of being in the Tigers’ lineup, but he will be batting ninth and is generally projected with a line around .265/.325/.410 and 10-15 HR – in other words no real value in our league. Jones’ Runs Created numbers last year dropped from 85 to 58, thanks in part to a 100-point drop in SLG. His best days are behind him.
Turnbow is in line to replace Gagne if he fails in Milwaukee, but he has two years of overall numbers that are just bad. Actually, the strikeouts have been great at over 11 K/9 the past two years, but the walk rate has been over 6 BB/9 over the same two years. Value comes only if he gets the chance to save again.
8. David Gilly
Best pick – Chad Billingsley – 15th round
There is only one real number I can find where Billingsley did not improve from 2006 to 2007 (his first true chance to start), and that is his HR/9 number of .92, up from .70. Billingsley’s career FB% is around 37.6% or just better than average, so the HR rate is not too much of a concern, especially pitching in Dodger Stadium. Besides that, all of his rate stats such as ERA, WHIP, K/9, BB/9, BABIP, LOB%, and BAA all made significant increases in 2007. And he is only 24 – which means he is still maturing.
Worst pick – Jorge Posada – 8th round
Posada is a fine catcher and should put up great positional numbers in the Yankees lineup. But he was taken as the fourth catcher overall behind the 3M’s – Martinez, Martin and McCann. Fourth is not crazy for Posada, but I think it started a run on catchers too early. In fact, 6 teams drafted their catcher before the 10th round was over. And that may not sound so bad, but that means that 6 catchers were drafted in the top 100 players. And that just can’t be justified. For example, in MLB.com’s top 100 fantasy list, only three are catchers. I imagine David drafted with a few thoughts of Posada’s 2007 numbers in his head. We have discussed this before, but Posada’s 2007 base stats just do not coincide with the rest of his career, and at 37, he can’t be expected to be that lucky again – especially with his incredible .389 BABIP.
9. Justin Jones
Best pick – Curtis Granderson – 8th round
News of Granderson’s broken finger dropped the value of this CF who had a 20-20-20-20-20-20-20-20-20 season (or something like that) in 2007. So this is a guarded pick, but even if Granderson misses three to four weeks from the time of the injury, he should be a steal in the 8th round. Granderson led all AL leadoff men in OPS in 2007 with .926 and the projections of Bill James, CHONE, Marcel and ZiPS all feel that Granderson will repeat his 2007 numbers in 2B, HR and RBI – all very valuable in our league.
Worst pick – Nick Swisher – 4th round
Again, I sort of understand this because first basemen were flying off the board so he had to have somebody, but Atkins, Adrian Gonzalez, Lee, and Konerko were still on the board – all of whom will probably have better power numbers than Swisher. Swisher is famous for his ability to get on base, but with his power, he might be sacrificing some HR (which were down by 13 from’06) for walks and other hits. That’s great in real life, “get on base….help the team,” but doesn’t do too much for us. He can play 1B or OF, so depending on how Justin’s other 1B (Todd Helton) does, this may all be a moot point.
10. Jason Kirksey
Best pick – Adam Wainwright – 15th round
I was all ready to put his pick of Kelvim Escobar in this slot, but then word comes today that his injury might be career-threatening, so that shot that idea. Anyway, Wainwright’s move from reliever to starter was an overwhelming success. While most of his numbers saw a bit of an uptick, understandable due to his innings being almost three times that of 2006, the one number that decreased significantly was his HR/9 from 0.72 to 0.58. This is promising for someone who is going to be the veritable ace of the staff at least until the all-star break. Wainwright is another groundball pitcher (48%), but with more than a third of his batted balls being flyballs, it is good that he is developing a skill of keeping balls in the park at a better rate.
Worst pick – Dontrelle Willis – 14th round
We all like looking for great value in the last quarter of the draft, but…

And now he moves to a tougher league for pitchers, albeit with a stellar offense behind him. There is also always talk of Comerica being a pitchers’ park, but in 2006 and 2007, it was very average, and actually a better park for hitters on average over the last three years than the Marlins’ stadium in Miami. That could spell trouble.
So there you have it, too much information that too few people don’t care about. I will do a brief recap mid-season of how things are going and then do a seasonal review looking back at these picks and deciding what the REAL best and worst value picks were for 2008.
I would love to hear your complaints or praise on your thoughts on the picks in general.